• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Roma Pizza - New Buffalo: Authentic, Family-Owned Pizzeria Serving Fresh, Memorable Pizza

Roma Pizza - New Buffalo is a beloved local pizzeria rooted in history since the mid-1970s, located at 17600 Red Arrow Hwy. Known for its fresh ingredients and authentic flavors, Roma delivers classic Italian dishes like sausage and pepperoni pizzas, homemade meatballs, and Italian beef sandwiches that evoke nostalgia and satisfy cravings. The warm, family-run atmosphere shines through friendly service and a vibrant dining vibe, enhanced by vintage touches like Dean Martin tunes and an arcade corner. Whether it’s the perfectly melted cheese pulls or the promise of a future patio, Roma Pizza is a must-visit for genuine, hearty pizza experiences in New Buffalo.

Roma Pizza - New Buffalo at a glance

  • Address 17600 Red Arrow Hwy, New Buffalo, MI 49117, United States
  • Phone +1 269-469-3698
  • Restaurant type Pizza restaurant .
  • Popular for Lunch , Dinner , Solo dining .

Photos & Gallery

Roma Pizza - New Buffalo: Reviews & Ratings

Paul BAUMGART
4

First time here. Pizza very good. Only ate half. Order small two (2) topping, more of medium size. Only down side was I noticed black specks on bottom of pizza, maybe burn corn meal?

Jeremy Spray
5

12_21_2024 My girlfriend and I ate here for the first time. I grew up next door and worked here in high school. I recently worked here 2012_2013. Nothing but memories in this building. My mom Brenda Spray and Nick Amicarelli opened this place in 1974 or 1976. The food today brought back tons of memories. Food and service was great. Nathan was great service.. We ordered a small sausage and pepperoni pizza and a Italian beef sandwich cheese, onion, green pepper, pepperchini.

Rachel Stallworth
5

Romas Pizza nailed it Exactly what I mean when I say I’m craving pizza. Fresh ingredients, homemade meatballs that were straight-up fire , and the staff/owners couldn’t have been friendlier. Dean Martin playing in the background was the icing on the cake while we ate—such a vibe. 10/10 would go back again (probably tomorrow). Can’t wait for the patio to be built next summer—it’s gonna be the perfect spot! -Rachel & Stacey

Charlie Burns
5

Great pizza, fresh salad and cold beer. Service was great and vibe was legit.

Landon Bell
5

Between the super friendly staff and the great pizza, I thoroughly enjoyed my visit to Romo Pizza. Who I assume was the owner had their kid sweeping floors and training up to be the next generation, I loved to see it. There was a cheap arcade setup with a ton of games, iirc it was 50 cents per play. Oh, and the cheese pull on the first slice was divine. Def glad we stopped in to check the place out. Bought some shirts and will surely be back when we’re in the area again.

Albert Chaharbakhshi
5

We got here around 7 on a Thursday night after giving up on the long lines at other nearby pizza places. I'm glad we did, as everyone agreed the pizza was delicious and exactly what we were looking for. The owner chatted with us as well and mentioned how long the place had been there, and it's easy to see why. Even though it seemed pretty empty, there was a constant stream of carry out going on and by the time we left, several more dinners had come in as well. Well definitely be back if we're in the area again.

Jesse Paz
5

Order a large pizza pepperoni with light cheese for delivery in an hour later they came with a cold pizza. I called the restaurant back and spoke to I believe was a manager. He fixed the problem and sent out a hot one ASAP. Excellent service excellent delivery driver.

Location

  • Roma Pizza - New Buffalo
    Roma Pizza - New Buffalo
    17600 Red Arrow Hwy, New Buffalo, MI 49117, United States Hotline: +1 269-469-3698

Roma Pizza - New Buffalo stands as a beacon of authentic, heartfelt pizzeria tradition nestled on Red Arrow Highway in Michigan. This spot is more than just a place to grab a slice; it’s a living local memory forged since the mid-1970s and continued today with genuine care and passion. Walking in, you’re enveloped by a warm, inviting atmosphere where Dean Martin softly croons, and the unmistakable scent of freshly baked dough fills the air.

The pizzas here aren’t just meals—they’re experiences. Each pie boasts fresh, high-quality ingredients with a perfect balance that delivers on classic Italian-American flavors. From the delightfully savory Italian beef sandwich loaded with cheese, onions, green peppers, and pepperoncini to the homemade meatballs praised for their fiery, robust taste, the menu captures comforting nostalgia with every bite. The cheese pull on the first slice, thick and gooey, signals the promise of great craftsmanship behind the counter.

Service complements the food beautifully. Staff members like Nathan, who provide friendly and attentive service, help elevate the visit, making guests feel like cherished family. The small touches, from the arcade lined with vintage games to the sight of younger generations training behind the scenes, enrich the experience, blending tradition with a welcoming community vibe.

Despite minor notes such as a slight burnt cornmeal taste noted by some, the overall impression remains thoroughly positive. Roma Pizza is a place where fresh salads, cold beer, and strong service come together effortlessly, creating a vibe that’s both lively and relaxed. Whether you’re craving a crispy, flavorful pizza or craving a sit-down meal with a hometown touch, this pizzeria delivers exactly what the pizza lover’s heart desires. It’s no surprise that patrons are looking forward eagerly to new additions like a patio, promising an even better setting next summer. Simply put, Roma Pizza isn’t just a meal—it’s a slice of New Buffalo’s soul.

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Wheelchair-accessible entrance
    • Wheelchair-accessible seating
    • Wheelchair-accessible toilet
  • Service options
    • Outdoor seating
    • Delivery
    • Takeaway
    • Dine-in
  • Payments
    • Credit cards